PRINTER'S NO. 545
No. 521 Session of 1999
INTRODUCED BY WILT, LEH, TIGUE, FARGO, READSHAW, FAIRCHILD,
RAMOS, SEYFERT, McCALL, GODSHALL, BELFANTI, HERSHEY, PLATTS,
BENNINGHOFF, CALTAGIRONE, HALUSKA, FORCIER, FEESE, SOLOBAY,
SURRA, MUNDY, M. COHEN, LEDERER, ARGALL, E. Z. TAYLOR,
SAINATO, SATHER, KENNEY, TRELLO, METCALFE, BARRAR, STABACK,
STEVENSON, YOUNGBLOOD, MICHLOVIC, ROSS, KAISER, ALLEN,
S. MILLER, MAHER, ROBERTS AND SAYLOR, FEBRUARY 10, 1999
REFERRED TO COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY, FEBRUARY 10, 1999
AN ACT
1 Amending Title 23 (Domestic Relations) of the Pennsylvania
2 Consolidated Statutes, providing for a presumption of
3 paternity of children born during a marriage; and further
4 providing for blood tests to determine paternity.
5 The General Assembly finds and declares as follows:
6 That the overriding public policy of this Commonwealth is
7 that a child born during a marriage shall be presumed to be the
8 issue of the husband. Marriages which continue to function as
9 family units should not be destroyed by disputes over parentage
10 of children conceived during the marriage. Third parties should
11 not be allowed to attack the integrity of a functioning marital
12 unit, and that, generally, members of that unit should not be
13 allowed to deny their identities as parents.
14 However, the General Assembly finds that the common law rule
15 followed by the Pennsylvania courts relating to the presumption
16 of paternity for a child born during a marriage is an ancient
1 concept that fails to conform with modern-day realities and
2 current scientific methods of determining parentage.
3 The General Assembly also declares that the purpose of this
4 act is to displace the common law rule relating to the
5 presumption of paternity for a child born during a marriage and
6 give the courts of this Commonwealth statutory guidance to
7 resolve disputes over paternity for children born during a
8 marriage.
9 The General Assembly of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania
10 hereby enacts as follows:
11 Section 1. Title 23 of the Pennsylvania Consolidated
12 Statutes is amended by adding a section to read:
13 § 5102.1. Paternity of child born during marriage.
14 (a) Presumption of paternity.--A child born during a
15 marriage is presumed to be the child of the marriage and the
16 issue of the husband.
17 (b) Rebuttable presumption.--The husband or wife may rebut
18 the presumption of paternity by a showing of any of the
19 following:
20 (1) the husband did not have access to the wife at the
21 time of conception;
22 (2) the husband was physically incapable of procreation
23 at the time of conception;
24 (3) the wife was engaged in an extra-marital
25 relationship at the time of conception; or
26 (4) the husband voluntarily completed a blood test which
27 determines that the husband could not be the father of the
28 child.
29 (c) Applicability of presumption.--The presumption of
30 paternity in subsection (a) shall apply in instances where the
19990H0521B0545 - 2 -
1 husband and wife cohabited at the time of the birth of the
2 child.
3 (d) Estoppel of paternity actions.--Notwithstanding
4 subsection (b), an action for paternity shall be estopped and
5 the presumption of paternity shall become irrebuttable if there
6 is clear and convincing evidence that the husband openly holds
7 out the child to be his and receives the child into his home for
8 a period of two or more years after the birth of the child.
9 Section 2. Section 5104(g) of Title 23 is amended to read:
10 § 5104. Blood tests to determine paternity.
11 * * *
12 (g) Effect on presumption of [legitimacy.--The] paternity.--
13 As provided in section 5102.1 (relating to paternity of child
14 born during marriage) the presumption of [legitimacy] paternity
15 of a child born during [wedlock] a marriage is overcome if the
16 court finds that the conclusions of all the experts as disclosed
17 by the evidence based upon the tests show that the husband is
18 not the father of the child.
19 Section 3. This act shall take effect in 60 days.
L3L23DMS/19990H0521B0545 - 3 -